Tag Archives: designers

The Ratings Measuring Stick – Part Two

Posted on

Today I want to talk for a minute about my husband.  No, my husband does not know how to crochet but he is one of those people you would call an “analytic thinker”.   To my complete and total surprise, he has taken a very keen interest in this blog and what it is intended for.  We have spent a few evenings sitting on our back deck discussing what information I want to include, whether or not I want to assign actual number or star ratings to patterns, who my target audience really is, and what my real goals are.  His best question to me yet came last night.  “Who are you writing to?  The designer or the people who buy the patterns?” Well, obviously I want to review patterns that fellow crocheters buy and NOT the designers themselves but I suppose I had strayed a bit off that original path because there are so many things that are purely a matter of personal preference.

Think about gauge for a second.  I believe, and I think most crocheters would agree with me, that gauge is a required element of a good crochet pattern.  However, there are a few different ways you can find the gauge of a piece.  You can do a vertical and horizontal swatch, you can simply chain a certain number of stitches, you can crochet the first 4 or 5 rounds of a pattern and then measure, or maybe you can crochet a section of that pattern that has a specific stitch pattern.  Do you see where I’m going with this?  My question was then, which method is the best method?  That is entirely subjective.  What I like may not be what you like.  So it would be very hard for me to place a rating star or number on a pattern based on my personal preferences and expect you to just take it as gospel truth.

So here is what I’m going to do.  I have created a template to use for all patterns I review.  There are concrete, verifiable elements on the template and there are subjective elements on the template.  I will give the straight dope on the concrete, verifiable elements without any bias to what I prefer.  Anything else on the list that is not concrete and verifiable is considered subjective and you will get my personal opinion on those things.  I would hate for you to base your decision to purchase or not purchase based upon subjective comments only.  Your style may not be my style.  My hope is that the concrete items will be your calling card as to whether you want to buy a pattern or not and all the rest is lagniappe (our fun Louisiana word for extras).  I also aim to provide you with full disclosure of my association with every pattern – where I purchased it (if I can remember), whether I have crocheted other patterns by this designer, if I personally know the designer, if the designer specifically asked for a review of their pattern, etc., so that there is no feelings of bias or inclusion.  I do not endorse any pattern designers and make a profit from that endorsement.

To recap before I put my first review up, which will be by the weekend –  I will give you the straight answers on the concrete questions that can be verified, I will give you my own opinion on additional items, and I will most likely give the pattern my own personal score in the form of a letter grade like you get in school.  I briefly considered using the letter grade scale from Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry but I hesitate to designate a pattern with a T for Troll should I have the unfortunate chance to come across such a pattern.  (By the way, I was placed in Gryffindor by the Sorting Hat on Pottermore!  Geaux Gryffs!)

I have created a separate page for my template which you can find by clicking the tab called Standard Checklist Template at the top of my blog page.  Until the weekend, get your crochet on!

The Ratings Measuring Stick – Part One

Posted on

Ok, so I’ve been thinking about this blog and how I was going to introduce my ratings method.  In the space of just the last few hours, I’ve had several changes of direction.  So, I think the best thing to do is to tell you what I look for in a good pattern and then tell you what I’ve heard from others on the subject.  If you add your own feedback to all of this, then I can compile a nice orderly list of what the majority of crocheters look for and then I can decide on a point system that would be understandable to all.

Here are my notes in the order in which they were written:

  1. Is the gauge given and if so, is it a full horizontal and vertical sampling (i.e. 14 dc and 9 rows = 4″) or only based on the length of a chain?
  2. Is the font easy to read?
  3. Does the pattern flow seamlessly from one part to the next or do you have to search for information?  Does the pattern give you direction as to where the next step can be found?
  4. Is contact information provided to reach the designer if you have questions or need support?
  5. Does the designer assign a difficulty rating to their pattern?
  6. Are there errors in stitch counts, typos, or misspellings?  How many?
  7. Is a hook size given?
  8. Does the designer state a recommended yarn either by weight, fiber or name brand?
  9. Once the item is complete, does it resemble or closely match the photo used for advertising?
  10. If a gauge was given (and you checked it!), did the item come out to the correct size?
  11. Are there adequate photos to explain more difficult stitches or how and where to sew on parts?
  12. Is there an abbreviation key?
  13. If there are special stitches, is there a clear explanation on how to execute them?  How about a picture tutorial?
  14. Does the designer restrict the pattern to personal use only, require a cottage license, request that you contact them first before selling any of  your items, or do they give you full permission to sell what you want?
  15. Does the pattern have a cluttered look or feel to it?
  16. Are measurements of the items provided?

Here is a synopsis of the feedback I got from a few fellow crocheters on what they expect to see in a good pattern and what they dislike as well:

  • Gauge – They have stated that they are amazed at the number of patterns they come across that does not list a gauge.  Many of the crocheters I discussed this with sell their crocheted items so it is crucial that a gauge be listed in order to get correct sizing.
  • Stitch counts – Amazingly enough, there are still patterns out there that do not list a stitch count at the end of every row.  Apparently there are enough of those types of patterns for this to be an issue since I also have that on my list which was compiled before I spoke with the group.
  • Measurements – Measurements and gauge go hand in hand.   When we speak of measurements, we want to know how tall a hat is supposed to be from top down to brim, or how wide a diaper cover is at the waistband, or what the rise of the cover is.  If your gauge checks out fine horizontally but not vertically, this could be a huge factor in getting the correct sizing.  More experienced crocheters can make adjustments by adding extra rows or changing hook sizes but without measurements and when you are thinking your gauge is alright because your swatch came up fine, you might find that the item you just made has to be frogged and adjusted because it’s too short/long/narrow/etc.
  • Typos and misspellings – Most people are not bothered by one or two typos or misspellings unless they affect the outcome of the finished item.  However, when there is a large amount of typos and misspellings, it can be annoying to many of us, especially those of us that are considered grammar and spelling sticklers.  It also gives the user the impression that the pattern designer just threw the pattern together and put it up for sale without bothering to have others test it and make corrections.
  • Sizing – This is two-fold.  A statement was made that it appears to be laziness on the part of the designer if they market a hat as being in multiple sizes but when you get the pattern you are given just one or two actual sizes and then told to change the hook size to make it larger or smaller.  The other issue mentioned was designers that break their child and adult sizes into two separate patterns thereby having the user purchase two patterns instead of one if they wish to sell the hat in every size.
  • Clutter – If it’s not necessary, don’t do it.  Rainbow colored fonts, single spacing, no division between sections, and pages of photo instruction are turn offs.

Now, while I was sitting here typing all of that up, other things popped into my head and then popped right back out.  Ha ha!  There are just so many things that make up a good pattern and there are so many things that can mess up a good pattern designer.  Part of designing, in my opinion, is also about turning your artistic talents off for a little while and applying  yourself to a little bit of technical writing.  Boring?  Yes, to me it is.  Necessary?  Yes, if you want to sell more patterns.  Crocheters talk.  Yes, we do.  It’s not meant to be mean or catty or demeaning to any designer out there but we talk to each other because we don’t want someone else to feel like we do – like our money was just wasted on a pattern we will never use because it’s too frustrating to wade through it.  Crocheting should be an enjoyable experience.  Why else would anyone do it, especially as little as it pays if it is your source of income.  (And if you are making a killing doing it, please pass the secret of your success on to me!)
And now I would love to hear your input.  What would you add or subtract from the lists above?  What is most important to you as a crochet enthusiast?  Let’s hear it in the comments section.  Ready?  Go!

Motherhood, WTF?

I'm the mom who makes you feel better about your parenting.

Keep Me In Stitchez: The Blog

Following my passion, one stitch at a time

Three J Q Designs

"...and if the band you're in starts playing different tunes, I'll see you on the dark side of the moon"

crochetedcouture.com & micheleproducts.ETSY.com

crochet is not just for grandma anymore!

By Hook or By Pen

Adventures in Yarn and Art

Kristen Lamb

Author, Blogger, Social Media Jedi

Motherhood, WTF?

I'm the mom who makes you feel better about your parenting.

Jonah said/Ben said

Quotes from my sons, for your entertainment.

JM Randolph, accidentalstepmom

adventures in half-assed stepparenting

ZukkaBlu

Crochet

solarpyxie

The greatest WordPress.com site in all the land!

thiscraftymomma

Just another WordPress.com site

Crochet with Raymond

The mad adventures of a lesbi@n hooker and her siamese cat!